Are Bamboo Rods As Good As Carbon Fiber Ones?

Is it realistic to expect that a vintage fishing can perform as well as or even better than current state-of-the-art rods? This problem has perplexed many avid fishermen, especially those with a fondness for fly fishing or spinning. Is it really worth all the effort of trying to find and buy a rod that is decades old?

Well, it is pretty much linked to what kind of fishing you are interested in. There is no doubt that cf (carbon fiber) has revolutionized the fishing rod industry, and is much, much better than fiberglass. So buying an old fiberglass rod would be a waste of money. Also, many old rods that have been used extensively have invariably sustained damage of one kind or another, and such damage may have compromised the strength and integrity of the rod. Who would want to take the chance that such a rod would not break under the strain of a trophy-sized fish?

However, when it comes to bamboo rods, and in particular split cane fishing rods, the answer is not so clear. The view that a well-built vintage bamboo fishing rod is better than even the best of the current crop of cf rods is widely held by anglers, especially those who like fly fishing and spinning. In particular, where accurate and long casting of light weights is paramount, cane rods seem to have the edge. Also, there is the aesthetic value of a bamboo rod, which lends it to be seen as more of a work of art than a tool for fishing.

Antique Rod Fishing Performance

Therefore, those who fish in sheltered water environments such as in fly fishing or spinning, would seem to benefit from buying a good bamboo rod. Of course, the same rule applies: a damaged rod is no good for fishing. Therefore you must check the bamboo sections carefully. Discoloration, water marks, scratches, crushes, holes and other significant damage are things to keep an eye out for. The vintage rod could be a bargain buy if the cane is in good condition and the owner persuaded to sell at a reasonable price. Apart from the cane and perhaps cork handle, any other part of the rod can probably be restored to their original condition by an expert for a few hundred dollars. You will find that the vintage rod will be more than up to the task of playing and landing decent sized fish if it is sound condition.

One name widely associated with magnificently crafted rods is England’s Milwards. Their unequalled level of build, finish, flexibility and kit made Milwards rods stand apart from others of their generation. The fittings were bronze, brass, silver, agate and silk, while the bamboo was usually Tonkin cane. Milwards fly fishing and spinning rods were designed to fit into specific fishing niches and therefore were often excellent match rods. For example, the Milwards FloatMaster Rod was perfect for casting float rigs, while the Milwards SwimVersa was magnificent at casting extremely lightweight baits or lures It is not surprising that Milwards rods are not often available for purchase, as they are cherished by their owners. One way of obtaining one is by enticing the owner to swap it to you in exchange for a vintage piece of fishing tackle of similar value.

To wrap up, don’t waste your time buying an old fiberglass rod but definitely consider a vintage bamboo fishing pole if you come across one either in good condition or restorable condition. Bamboo fishing rods can also increase in value over time and are exquisite pieces of craftsmanship in their own right. It really is a no-brainer to purchase a quality antique bamboo pole if you come across one in the right condition at the right price!